A dispute between Germany and Italy over migrant returns has escalated into one of the sharpest bilateral conflicts in recent European migration history, threatening the credibility of the EU’s newly implemented asylum framework.
The confrontation centres on Germany’s attempt to transfer three asylum seekers to Italy under the EU’s Asylum and Migration Management Regulation (AMMR), which took effect in mid-June. Italy has refused to accept them, arguing that a bilateral ‘Dubliners amnesty’ reached in December 2025 extinguishes all pre-June take-back claims. A planned transfer of a Somali woman on August 19 did not take place.
Dual-Regime Legal Battle
Both sides claim the law supports their position. Under Article 92 of the AMMR, applications lodged before June 12 remain subject to Dublin III rules, while those filed after fall under the new regulation. Germany’s interior ministry insists that ‘the functioning of the Dublin system is an indispensable condition for the success of the Common European Asylum System.’ Italy’s foreign ministry counters that ‘all alleged Dublin migrants who moved before 12 June are covered by the bilateral amnesty; there are therefore zero returns due.’
Italy has widened the dispute far beyond the three pending transfers. The Italian Interior Ministry released figures claiming that since Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni took office in October 2022, German aid organisations have brought around 22,500 migrants to Italian ports out of approximately 42,300 arrivals on private rescue vessels. Rome puts the German share at nearly two-thirds.
Financial Demands and Rescue Ship Threats
Italian Interior Minister Matteo Piantedosi has demanded Berlin provide funds to care for migrants earmarked for return, refusing to discuss take-backs until the financial question is resolved. Deputy Prime Minister Matteo Salvini went further, threatening to deny safe harbour to German-flagged rescue vessels if Berlin fails to cooperate.
Legal experts note that refusing safe harbour would breach international maritime law and expose Italy to sanctions. Any vessel in open waters must adhere to its flag country’s laws, and the flag state bears responsibility for all people on board, including those rescued at sea. At least 872 people have died or gone missing on the central Mediterranean route this year, according to the International Organization for Migration.
EU Pact Under Strain
The AMMR was designed to replace the dysfunctional Dublin system with a fairer framework for distributing responsibility. It includes a solidarity mechanism allowing member states to contribute through relocations, financial payments, or operational support. But the Germany-Italy standoff exposes whether this toolbox can reconcile frontline states’ concerns about disproportionate burden with northern states’ insistence on curbing secondary movements.
European diplomats worry the clash could set a precedent that unravels the pact before it has had a chance to function. The dispute comes as EU countries prepare for the next round of policy coordination on migration, with the credibility of the entire system at stake.
discussion